The Ron Gidwitz campaign
had a stark warning for Judy Baar Topinka last week. "If you think this ad
is tough, just wait."
Gidwitz, who is running
for governor as a Republican, aired the first negative ad of the campaign last
week, then dismissed Topinka's rebuttals as mere whining and vowed he would
ignore any attempt by the Illinois Republican Party to browbeat them into
pulling the spot.
The Gidwitz ad claims that
Topinka "doubled spending" in her office, approved billions in new
borrowing and proposed a sales tax increase.
Only one of the charges is
completely true.
The doubled spending claim
is particularly onerous and one that can't possibly be made with a straight
face. The Gidwitz campaign claims Topinka's payroll costs doubled since she
took office in 1995, which is technically true, but doesn't take into account
that two state programs were transferred to the treasurer's office during that
time and that she drastically reduced headcount and administrative costs after
she took control.
Topinka is also required
by law to sign off on longterm borrowing plans when both chambers approve and
the governor signs them into law. And she did back a sales tax increase when
she was in the state Senate, but that was a compromise floated in order to reduce
the "granny tax" on nursing home beds.
More negative ads are
planned, however, and the Gidwitz campaign broadly hinted last that the current
spot is tame by comparison.
During one recent
conversation with the campaign, an analogy was made between the Gidwitz
advertising plan and the House Republican's 2004 assault on former Democratic
state Rep. Bill Grunloh. Grunloh, an appointed legislator, was repeatedly
battered and beaten during the '04 campaign. His brief voting record was picked
apart and distorted, his family business ties were vilified, his integrity just
about wiped out. By the end, Grunloh was reduced to publicly pleading that the
negative attacks cease. Pretty please. He was clobbered at the polls.
But a couple of months
ago, State Republican Party Chairman Andy McKenna asked that all the candidates
play fair and avoid negative assaults. He also indicated that he would try to
referee disputes between them.
A couple of days after the
Gidwitz ad appeared, the Republican state central committee held an emergency
meeting to discuss the Gidwitz attack. Topinka had requested the meeting.
The meeting resulted in
the first-ever rebuke by the Republican state central committee of a GOP
gubernatorial candidate, but was immediately met with a defiant response.
Gidwitz refused to pull or alter the ad.
"In our opinion,
questions exist about the accuracy of the charges in your current advertisement
that need to be resolved," wrote party chairman Andy McKenna on behalf of
the state party's central committee. The diplomatically worded, but nonetheless
unprecedented letter urged Gidwitz to produce documentation to defend his
charges, and if he can't, "we respectfully request that you edit the
content of the message to accurately and truthfully reflect your opponent's
record."
Gidwitz eventually
released a statement that accused Topinka of hiding behind "Republican
Party insiders" instead of defending her record, adding, "If she
can't stand on her own two feet, she certainly can't clean up the mess in Springfield."
Whatever happens, the
reality is that far more people will see the Gidwitz ad than will hear or read
about the party's rebuke, so the conflict will stay mostly among political
wonks. A political strategist friend points out that the negative attacks will
undoubtedly hurt Topinka, but said he has his doubts that Gidwitz can win.
Negative ads tend to send
voters flocking to other candidates, away from both the attacker and the
attackee. A strong, consistently positive campaign by conservative Republican
candidate Jim Oberweis, my friend said, could drive voters to him.
I'm not so sure about that
last part since Oberweis' negatives are so high because of his antics in
previous campaigns. But unless Bill Brady, the fourth candidate in the race,
can raise a whole lot of money very fast, then Oberweis will likely drive his
numbers up with his new positive ad. Other voters may just head to the
"undecided" column to wait and see what happens next.
The Gidwitz campaign has
been making a big deal out of alleged ethics issues with Topinka, so that might
be the next TV assault. Stay tuned.
-30-
Rich Miller also publishes
Capitol Fax, a daily political newsletter. He can be reached at
thecapitolfaxblog.com