What Does a Vendetta against Immigrants Cost?
By Richard W. Crockett
What can Monmouth and surrounding
communities learn from the Postville, Iowa experience? Both towns have
meatpacking plants and both plants employed large numbers of immigrants. In
Monmouth it is Farmland Foods, which processes pork. In Postville it was Agriprocessors which was a kosher
meatpacking operation, and
at its peak supplied 60 percent of
the nation’s kosher beef and 40 percent of the nation’s kosher poultry. The
plants in both Monmouth and Postville have been the largest employers in their
respective communities and counties. In Monmouth’s case, Farmland is also the
largest employer in Warren, Knox, Henderson, and Mercer counties. Postville is
a community whose population over the last ten years has ranged from a low of
approximately 1300 when a previously closed packinghouse reopened, to an
estimated high of approximately 3500 toward the “end” of the period. The census of 2000, some eight years
ago, put the official population of Postville at 2273. In Iowa, recent
headlines in the press have proclaimed, “Postville streets empty as immigration
officials return,” “Postville real estate firm could close, owner says,” and
“Agriprocessors’ Bankruptcy Leaves Iowa Town Flailing.”
Postville is suffering severe
economic stress as a result of recent events. The events are the aftermath of a deliberate governmental
anti-immigration policy; an Immigration Agency raid on May 12, 2008 in search
of illegal immigrants employed by Agriprocessors, and the fallout from the raid
has been a disaster for the local businesses and community.
I will confess my bias at the
outset. The Mexican immigrant
population, residing and working in Monmouth, are good people who add richness
to the semi-rural midwestern culture.
They have a reputation, in the main, as persons who work hard, pay their
bills and rents and support the community businesses. In Postville until May
2008, the immigrant population was primarily Guatemalan, and the Guatemalans
and others in Postville supported their community also. The May 12, 2008 anti-immigration raid
in Postville led to 389 arrests and 270 immediate convictions, representing
about one-third of the workforce, which set the Agriprocessors plant reeling. Because many of the workers had
families, for the plant to lose a worker is for the community to lose an entire
family. A repeat raid on Election
Day, November 4, 2008 emptied the streets in Postville, but netted only one
arrest. (Never mind why Election Day was chosen, but it does suggest a
political as well as law enforcement motive.)
According to Postville, Iowa City
Clerk-Administrator, Darcy Radloff, even though Agriprocessors filed Chapter 11
Bankruptcy November 4, 2008, in a New York bankruptcy court, a case was already
in preparation prior to a foreclosure notice that it had received for alleged
non-payment of a 35,000,000 dollar debt to First Bank Business Capital of St.
Louis, Missouri, and it had been continuing to operate with a skeleton crew in
its poultry operation until Friday, November 14. (If you ever want to eat
poultry again, you don’t want to know all of the details of the final days.) Anyway, the remaining workers
apparently did not get paid on Friday November 14, and as a result on Monday
November 17, the place looked pretty deserted.
For a time Agriprocessors had
employed the services of staffing agencies, and Jacobson Staffing of Des
Moines, Iowa, had since the May 12, 2008 Immigration Agency raid supplied
“legal” workers to the company. Many of these were American citizens described
as “transients,” some recently released from prison, as well as “legal” persons
from some 20 other countries. According to Radloff, the arrest
rate in Postville jumped up significantly following the replacement of the
Guatemalans with the “transients” and “legals.”
Creditors have joined to file
motions for a change of venue and to move the bankruptcy proceedings from New
York to an Iowa bankruptcy court, since most of the creditors are located in
the Midwest. According to a report in the Des Moines Register, Agriprocessors
“owes nearly 400 creditors between $50 million and $100 million.” Some of the claims against the company
include $10,000,000 in fines by the state of Iowa for alleged labor violations,
MetLife Ag Investments of Overland Park, Kansas has claims of $9.6 million,
National City Commercial Capital of Ohio claims $2.9 million due for leased
equipment, and Jacobson Staffing claims it is owed more than $800,000.
Two Postville landlords, Nevel
properties and GAL investments have taken a hit. Nevel Properties owns about 67 homes, estimated value at
about 4.7 million and rents primarily to the Jewish Community associated with
the kosher meatpacking plant in Postville. GAL Investments owns 135 units in about 60 properties
consisting of apartments and homes, according to City Clerk-Administrator,
Darcy Radloff, and rented to many of the workers in the plant. The last report that Radloff had of GAL
Investments was on Friday November 14, and they had 25 tenants who were paying
their rent, 75 vacancies where the tenants had left following the original May
12, 2008 raid by ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement), and 35 units are
still occupied, but not paying rent. Gabay Menahem, the president of GAL, was
quoted in the DesMoines Register on November 12, 2008 as saying, “In a month or
two, we might have to close shop. We’ve
gotten virtually no rent in almost five months. Nobody gets my side of the story. Everybody blames the landlords.” At one point the landlords
had an arrangement with Agriprocessors to withhold rents from workers
paychecks, allowing new workers to acquire a place of residence upon arriving
in Postville with no money. Recently, the rents had not been forthcoming from
Agriprocessors, even though the money had allegedly been withheld from
paychecks.
Postville has a municipal water
supply and the city recently sent out 54 notices of disconnection and got
responses from 32, discovering 22 in which the units were apparently vacant.
The local utility company has abated shut offs for the time being. Area banks hold mortgages on many of
these properties. There are three
banks, which include Citizens State Bank in Postville, Freedom Bank in
Postville, and Luana Bank in Luana, nearby. Radloff estimates the average home price in the community to
be at about $85,000.
Two stores have closed so far, a
Mexican clothing store and a Guatemalan convenience store. There is a Mexican
Restaurant, which has exhibited low traffic lately and a Jewish Clothing store,
which seems to be “hanging on by a thread.”
Beyond the job losses and personal
dislocations flowing from the May 12, 2008 immigration raid, there are
additional personal costs in criminal charges brought against not only workers,
but also management personnel. The
Iowa Attorney General’s Office charged the company and five individuals with
9,311 child labor law violations, according to a complaint and affidavit filed
in Allamakee County on September 9, 2008.
These are misdemeanor charges and are against Abraham Aaron Rubashkin,
“principal owner and president; Shalom Rubashkin, plant manager and an officer
in the company; Elizabeth Billmeyer, human resources manager; and Laura
Althouse 38, and Karina Freund 29, management employees in the human resources
division,” according to a November 11 story published in the Cedar Rapids
Gazette. Conviction of these misdemeanors could result in up to 30 days in jail
per violation (9311 of them) and fines ranging from $65 -$625 for each count. There are 32 victims under the age of
18, some of them under 17.
Human Resources personnel were also
facing federal felony charges. Karina
Freund, who worked in the human resources department was arrested September 9
and charged with harboring illegal immigrants and assisting them in preparing
false documents. She was indicted September 17. Her trial date is scheduled for January 20, 2009. If convicted, she could be sentenced to
five years in prison and $250,000 in fines, a “special assessment” of $100 and
three years of “supervised release.”
Laura Althouse of Postville, Iowa a co-worker was arrested September 9
and indicted September 17. She was charged with “aiding and abetting document
fraud, aiding and abetting aggravated identity theft, and conspiracy to harbor
undocumented aliens for financial gain.”
On Wednesday October 29, she pleaded guilty in Federal Court to
“conspiracy to harbor undocumented immigrants for financial gain,” and
“aggravated identity theft.” This plea could result in up to two-year sentence
in the identity theft charge and up to ten years in jail on the conspiracy
charge and a $250,000 fine on each.
She awaits sentencing.
Two other supervisors were also
arrested. The July 9, 2008 page of Essential Estrogen reported Juan Carlos
Guerrero-Espinoza, 35, was charged and convicted with having conspired with
others, and aiding and abetting his employer, in hiring more than ten
individuals known to be undocumented and unable to legally work in the United
States. Upon conviction, Espinoza faces a possible ten years in prison, a
$500,000 fine, $200 in “special assessments,” and “supervised release for up to
six years.” Espinoza became a legal resident in 2002. Martin De La Rosa-Loera, 43, pleaded guilty to charges of
aiding and abetting the use of fraudulent identity documents and encouraging
aliens to illegally reside in the United States. De La Rosa-Loera became a naturalized citizen in 2006.
A third supervisor, Hasom Amara,
44, who allegedly required workers to buy cars from him with illegal fraudulent
registration in order to keep their jobs or have more agreeable job assignments
is still sought by authorities and according to one account in the Iowa
Independent written by Lynda Waddington in June, he has fled to Israel.
The biggest fish caught in the INS
net appears to be Sholom M. Rubashkin, former CEO of Agriprocessors. Sholom is the son of the company’s
founder, A. A. Rubashkin, and was arrested October 30, 2008. He is charged with “conspiracy to
harbor undocumented aliens for profit, aiding and abetting document fraud, and
aiding and abetting aggravated identity theft.” If convicted of all of these charges, he could be looking at
up to 20 years in prison. The Feds
found phony blank immigration document cards in the Agriprocessors Human
Resources offices.
The principal lesson is that the
country needs to fix its broken immigration policy and do so with the
recognition that market forces are overwhelming the legal restrictions on
immigration. I think this country
can work out something with Mexico and other Western Hemisphere nations, which
allows for workers in jobs such as those in the meatpacking industry to be here
legally. It is also a lesson against the crude exploitation of workers because
of their vulnerable status. Much
of the evidence for the Federal case Agriprocessors came from persons who had
grievances, and who were working inside the plant in Postville. Finally, there
are the economic costs associated to the plant closure. Not only are business failures in
Postville, but there are now national shortages of Kosher meats throughout the
United States. Maybe we can learn.
12/4/08