On Winning and Losing
By
Richard W. Crockett
The danger of ÒlosingÓ and the virtue of ÒwinningÓ
the war in Iraq is a campaign theme of John McCain. He speaks against Òwaving
the white flag of surrenderÓ in which McCain apparently envisions American
soldiers and Marines crossing the Tigris or Euphrates rivers and throwing their
weapons in a huge pile in front of Al-Qaeda fighters whose faces are wrapped in
scarves and who are holding machine guns over the Americans, in the manner that
the Germans surrendered to American soldiers on the Elbe river at Tangermunde
in Germany in World War II? If he does not envision that scenario, he is being
disingenuous. In the phrase,
Òwhite flag of surrender,Ó he is using a symbolic portrayal that he does not
believe, himself. It is nothing
less than misleading campaign rhetoric. So much for the Òstraight talk
express.Ó The essence of this view is the fear of embarrassment that Al-Qaeda
might claim
that it defeated the United States, or that they could somehow claim a victory if the United
States were to choose to leave, and which ÒdefeatÓ McCain wants to associate
with Senators Obama and Clinton.
Regrettably, on the day that the body count of
Americans has reached 4,000, this pitch resurrects the old choice between saving
face and saving lives. In contending for this view McCain apparently believes
that it is better
to save face than to save lives.
Indeed, it demonstrates a callous willingness of John McCain and
proponents of this view to allow someone elseÕs son or daughter to die in a
cause that is not a legitimate American cause in order merely to save
face. It is not enough to conjure
up a long countenance and through its stern expression, lament in
pseudo-serious tone the loss of American lives and treasure. It would be so embarrassing to be
embarrassed, right? I know, it is
very difficult to acknowledge a stupid mistake, and Senator McCain, George
Bush, Dick Cheney, and the Neo-cons were guilty of a stupid mistake, and all of
them refuse steadfastly to admit that it was a stupid mistake. Others were also
guilty of making a stupid mistake, many of them Democrats in Congress,
including Hillary Clinton, but many of the Democrats have come to recognize the
stupidity of their mistake, and have embraced a fresh view of the war. McCain,
Bush and Cheney have not. Their apparent conclusion is that more of our sons
and daughters should die in order to avoid a confession by McCain, Bush and
Cheney that they made a stupid mistake.
In order to defend this irresponsible point of view they argue that
these innocent American victims of their failed policy are somehow defending
American Freedom. I would
rather see McCain, Bush and CheneyÕs faces red than more young Americans dead.
The war in Iraq has nothing to do with defending American freedom.
Defining ÒlosingÓ and ÒwinningÓ involves the question
of what is it that we are losing and winning? If we Òwin,Ó do we somehow enhance our American freedom, or
do we give up a measure of it in the name of national security, as has been the
case under the Bush AdministrationÕs first two terms through the excesses of
their Justice Department. Do we ÒwinÓ cheaper oil from IraqÕs abundant
inventory? Or do we lose more in dollars shipped to the Middles East to offset
the shortfall in the world market in part because IraqÕs oil production is down
by one third and we are now facing the prospect of four dollar per gallon
gasoline? Do we ÒwinÓ the opportunity to ÒreconstructÓ Iraq (to engage in the
nation-building supposedly hated by George Bush) rather than to reconstruct
American infrastructure, health care, education, social security, and the
economy? Do we win the opportunity
to saddle our children and grandchildren with the costs of a war that wipes out
their collective economic future?
And on losing, do we ÒloseÓ our status as
international bully? Or more benignly put, do we lose our reputation as
international Òbull in the China shopÓ? Do we lose the need to go into
Òinternational rehabÓ to cleanse ourselves of our addiction to belligerency and
arrogance? As Jefferson prefaced
his remarks in the Declaration of Independence, we might want to think of this
Òout of a decent respect to the opinions of mankind.Ó
The irony of this discussion is that the foreign
policy choices before us have nothing to do with winning and losing. Bush took us to war to topple Saddam
Hussein. That has been done. He
didnÕt want to Ònation-build.Ó That has not been avoided. Anything beyond that
is mission creep. If one truly
believes in the self-determination of peoples, it is time to come home and
leave Iraq to the Iraqis.
3/27/08