Book
Review
Lynn McKeown
Hope and the danger of slipping
The Audacity of Hope:
Thoughts on Reclaiming the American Dream, by Barack Obama. Crown Publishers,
2006. $25.00.
I approached this book with some degree of misgiving. Books by
politicians tend to consist of dry generalities and high purpose in boring
prose. Often they are actually written by a ghost writer. This book, according
to an interview on Amazon.com, was actually written by Obama, first in longhand
and then typed. I could believe this – it is a well-written, often
personal book, with much thoughtful discussion of contemporary politics. It is
not always easy reading, often dealing with abstract political principles, but
leavened with many personal stories and an appealing frankness and humor. I
might have expected this after reading ObamaÕs first book, Dreams from My Father, which I reviewed earlier, and which is also
an engrossing, interesting book. (If Obama is elected President, he might be
the best writer in that office since Theodore Roosevelt.)
In that earlier book, Obama told the story of growing up
without his black father (who left the family when Barack was two years old),
of being raised by his white mother and grandparents, then living for a time in
Indonesia when his mother remarried a man from that country. He also told of later experiences
living in the eastern U.S. where he attended Ivy League schools, later
experiences as a civil rights lawyer and community organizer in Chicago, and
journeying to Kenya to meet relatives there. This second book is more a book of
political principles, though it also contains many of ObamaÕs own life
experiences in later years, especially the two years he had spent as U.S.
Senator from Illinois at the time of publishing this book.
From the beginning of Audacity
of Hope (a title he borrowed, ironically, from a sermon by his
controversial former pastor, Jeremiah Wright), Obama asks for a change in American politics –
which he describes as a Òdead zoneÓ of partisan warfare – to an atmosphere
in which there is bipartisan cooperation to meet the challenges facing the
nation. The book was written and
published after ObamaÕs widely noted keynote speech at the 2004
Democratic Convention, in which he called for going beyond the ÒredÓ and ÒblueÓ political culture
wars mentality and toward work for the common good. He mentions that he cannot
take seriously such right-wing commentators as Ann Coulter or Sean Hannity, but
also finds some on the left prone to exaggeration when they say that America is
becoming Òfascist.Ó And he notes with approval the ÒcordialityÓ he finds
extending across the aisle in the Senate among older members such as Republican
John Warner and Democrat Robert Byrd, a cordiality whose absence makes more
difficult the compromises necessary in democratic government. (Obama has an
interesting story of a private meeting with Byrd, one of the grand old men of
the Senate.)
Near the beginning of the book, Obama tells the story of his
visit, with other new legislators, to the White House, including a funny
incident when President Bush offered him a squirt of hand sanitizer. The
President also took him aside and offered him some advice: Obama, the President
said, had a Òbright future,Ó but ÒWhen you get a lot of attention like youÕve been
getting, people start gunninÕ for ya. And it wonÕt necessarily just be coming
from my side, you understand. From yours, too. EverybodyÕll be waiting for you
to slip, know what I mean? So watch yourself.Ó
Obama goes on to say that Democratic audiences are surprised
when he tells them he doesnÕt Òconsider George Bush a bad man,Ó and believes
Òhe and members of his Administration are trying to do what they think is best
for the country.Ó Obama makes clear here and elsewhere in the book that he
thinks Bush and the Republicans are Òwrong-headedÓ in many of their policies,
and he spells out that wrong-headedness in some detail. But he finds most
Republicans Òpretty much like everybody else, possessed of the same mix of
virtues and vices, insecurities and long-buried injuries, as the rest of us,Ó
and he tends Òto recognize in them values I share.Ó But ObamaÕs vision for
America is different in many ways.
Audacity of Hope is divided into nine main chapters: Republicans and Democrats,
Values, Our Constitution, Politics, Opportunity (dealing with the economy),
Faith, Race, The World Beyond Our Borders, and Family. Probably not many voters
will read this book (WeÕre told that Americans donÕt read many books of any
kind), and thatÕs a shame because it provides a thoughtful discussion on many
problem areas of American life and would give them a good idea of what makes
Obama tick. It is a highly intelligent book by a writer who was for a time a
professor of constitutional law, but also a down-to-earth book with many anecdotes,
including stories of the authorÕs
own life with his wife and two daughters, even the problems and conflicts of a
marriage in which the couple are necessarily pursuing their lives and
responsibilities in separate cities much of the time. In a number of instances,
Obama relates his discussion of the nationÕs problems – the economy, for
instance – to problems encountered by residents of Galesburg. (Those who
saw ObamaÕs Democratic Convention speech will remember his references to
Galesburg at that time.)
There is currently an attempt by ÒconservativesÓ and
Republicans to paint Obama as an
empty-headed, Òfar-leftÓ Òelitist.Ó It probably wonÕt work, and certainly wonÕt
work with anyone who has read either of his books. Audacity of Hope is a call to return to the moderate liberal
tradition of the best programs of Franklin Roosevelt, Harry Truman, John
Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson, though recognizing the new world of globalization
and terrorism. Obama finds much wrong with the conservative Republican hegemony
of recent decades, including the
invasion of Iraq and what he considers a neglect of the less fortunate in our
society. But he is not a pacifist – he will undoubtedly disappoint those
who think military action and a strong military capability are always wrong
– and he gives much more weight to religion than may be comfortable to
some. But in fact, one feels he is rooted in the Judeo-Christian belief –
or the basic moral conviction, if you will – that we are Òour brotherÕs
keeper.Ó That is also a core liberal democratic belief and seems to this reader
to be a genuine core element of ObamaÕs approach to politics.
Now that Obama is running for president, he is finding out the
truth of George W. BushÕs comments about everyone ÒgunninÕÓ for him, including
some on his own Òside.Ó The Obama presidential campaign is now a target of the right and to a lesser extent the
left. There is a campaign of lies and distortion, Òswift-boating,Ó as it was
called during the last presidential campaign, coming from the right. (The Obama
campaign, learning from the past, has developed a quick response policy they
hope will blunt swift-boating attacks.) And there is also sniping from the
left, who sometimes see Obama, like Hillary Clinton, as insufficiently anti-war
and anti-establishment. This book will probably not reassure many on either the
right or left (if they should take the trouble to read it). They will
recognize, though, if they are at all honest, that it was written by an
idealistic but savvy and highly knowledgeable man with much political talent.
It is an attempt, one that may be overly optimistic and Òhopeful,Ó to promote a
politics with less grandstanding and belligerence and more intelligent
discussion and wise compromise.
08/14/08